Advertisers:
advertise on this site


Kenyan Vice President Kalonzo Musyoka Discusses Ongoing Developments in East Africa

Vice President Musyoka calls for the international community to devote more resources to fight terrorism in Somalia, in part by strenghtening the capacity of the Somali government.

Joseph Stiglitz on the Battle of Ideas Over the American Economy

The Nobel Prize-winning economist criticizes the Obama administration's economic policies and argues for a second stimulus and more effective financial regulation.

Daniel Levy and Jim Gerstein on a New Poll of Israeli Attitudes

New America Foundation/Middle East Task Force Director Daniel Levy and pollster Jim Gerstein discuss a new survey of Israeli attitudes toward Obama, Netanyahu, and the peace process.

More videos are available on the Video Archives Page
The Washington Note is now a member of the Political Insiders advertising network:
Find out more...

VA Loan and VA Refinance
Information from VA Mortgage Center



ADVERTISE SEND FEEDBACK OR TIPS CONTACT DETAILS
Support The Washington Note

Using PayPal

Peering Into Ahmad Chalabi's Cesspool & What About New Jersey, Virginia and New York City?

Share / Recommend - Comment - Print - Wednesday, Nov 09 2005, 9:57AM

Ahmed_Chalabi.jpg

Democrats won big in the New Jersey and Virginia Governor's races -- and a pragmatist who happens to be Republican won big in New York City. Lots of folks don't like Bloomberg, but in my mind, he's an old-line Republican centrist, and we need those back in bigger numbers.

The centrist Governor in California who went astray by getting in the way of gay civil rights and cuddling up too much with fundamentalist zealots got chastened -- BIG TIME -- with all four of his ballot initiatives crashing and burning. Maybe Arnold will now isolate the far right.

And Ron Fournier of the Associated Press gets today's prize for giddiest lead into an election story:

Iraq, Katrina, CIA leak, Harriet Miers. Things couldn't possibly get any worse for President Bush.

Wait, they just did.

Bush put his wispy political prestige on the line in the Virginia governor's race and lost Tuesday when the candidate he embraced in a last-minute campaign stop was soundly defeated. While there are many reasons for Jerry Kilgore's defeat, chief among them his poor campaign, giddy Democrats said the Virginia race as well as a Democratic victory in New Jersey prove that Bush is a political toxin for Republicans.

BUT THAT WAS YESTERDAY. . .

I just met a room full of smart people in Prague, ages ranging from 18 to 68, and all of them think Chalabi is a huckster who deceived the White House into taking on his war. They think the White House then deceived the American public -- and now wants to keep the lies going. I am impressed with level of awareness of Inside-the-Beltway scandals here in the Czech Republic.

Today, 2 p.m. -- 1150 17th Street, NW. In case, the Deputy Prime Minister has been reading this blog, you might want to stop by at 1:45. Lots of folks will be there. Talk to the press. They want to talk to you.

And be sure to talk to Mr. Chalabi. If it's pretty noisy with all the traffic and all -- clear your throat, fill your lungs, and greet him loudly. Poke him with the right questions. . .and then there is that "Citizen's Arrest" matter -- discussed below (this was a fantastic idea of Josh Marshall's). But if anyone does try this, don't get hurt -- Chalabi is not worth it. He has burly, armed thugs -- and I don't want any of you going down on the steps of AEI, though the thought of martyrs against him gets well. . .I'm not going to go there.

In any case, don't be rash. Be loud, peaceful, constructive, non-violent. . .if you plan to attend. The same goes for those greeting Deputy Prime Minister Chalabi on Friday afternoon at the Council on Foreign Relations.

To remind yourself of some of the outrageous schemes and lies Chalabi has hoisted on us -- as well as some token commentary from people like Colin Powell about Chalabi, let me share something that the Think Progress issued (excerpts):

Remarks by Colin Powell, 12 June 2003:
I can't substantiate [Chalabis] claims. He makes new ones every year.

A Short Rap Sheet on Ahmad Chalabi:

PENTAGON FUNDED CHALABI TO PROVIDE RATIONALE FOR WAR: The Pentagon's Defense Intelligence Agency paid the INC $335,000 a month in the lead-up to the Iraq war to gather intelligence. In all, the Bush White House has given the INC at least $39 million over the past 5 years.

CHALABI'S IRAQI NATIONAL CONGRESS WAS MAJOR SOURCE OF DATA FOR PENTAGON OFFICE OF SPECIAL PLANS: According to a report in the New Yorker, analysts based in the Pentagon's Office of Special Plans "relied on data gathered by other intelligence agencies and also on information provided by the Iraqi National Congress, or I.N.C., the exile group headed by Ahmad Chalabi." "You had to treat [the I.N.C.] with suspicion," a former Middle East station chief said of Chalabi's people. 'The I.N.C. has a track record of manipulating information because it has an agenda. It's a political unit -- not an intelligence agency.'"

CHALABI ATTENDED PLANNING MEETING AT THE PENTAGON JUST DAYS AFTER 9/11 ATTACKS: On September 18, 2001, Richard Perle convened a two-day meeting of the Defense Policy Board, a group that advises the Pentagon. Chalabi, who was a guest speaker at this meeting, made a presentation on the Iraqi threat.

CHALABI STOVEPIPED INTEL TO BUSH; DISSENTING CIA AND STATE ANALYSES REMAINED SECRET: According to The New Yorker, "Chalabi's defector reports were. . .flowing from the Pentagon directly to the Vice-President's office, and then on to the President, with little prior evaluation by intelligence professionals." State Dept. Intelligence expert Greg Thielmann said, "There was considerable skepticism throughout the intelligence community about the reliability of Chalabi's sources, but the defector reports were coming all the time. Knock one down and another comes along. Meanwhile, the garbage was being shoved straight to the President." The INC also takes credit for providing raw, unsubstantiated information directly to John Hannah, then-special assistant for national security in Vice President Dick Cheney's office.

CHALABI PROVIDED AGENT CURVEBALL TO AFFIRM SUPPOSED EXISTENCE OF SADDAM'S BIOLOGICAL WEAPONS LABS: "A U.S. official confirmed that defectors from Chalabi's organization had provided suspect information to numerous Western intelligence agencies. 'It's safe to say he tried to game the system,' the official said." A discredited INC defector to Germany who was code-named 'Curveball' was the chief source of information on Iraq's supposed fleet of mobile germ weapons factories. Curveball was the brother of a top lieutenant to Ahmed Chalabi, the group's leader and now a member of the Iraqi Governing Council.

CHALABI PLANTED FABRICATED NEWS STORIES: Chalabi was the source for discredited news stories about Iraq and weapons of mass destruction which were penned by New York Times reporter Judith Miller. In 2001, Miller wrote a front-page story about claims that Saddam had twenty secrety WMD sites hidden in Iraq. The information turned out to be bogus. Chalabi's group arranged Miller's interview with the source and, according to the New Yorker, Miller's exclusive story came just "three days after [the source] had shown deception in a polygraph test administered by the C.I.A. at the request of the Defense Intelligence Agency."

CHALABI SHRUGS OFF MISLEADING U.S.: "Mr Chalabi, by far the most effective anti-Saddam lobbyist in Washington, shrugged off charges that he had deliberately misled US intelligence. 'We are heroes in error,' he told the Telegraph in Baghdad."

CHALABI ACCUSED OF PASSING U.S. SECRETS TO IRAN: In June 2004, Chalabi came under investigation for allegations that he passed secret intelligence to Iran. Chalabi is accused of telling the Iranian government that the U.S. had broken the code it used for secret communications. National Security Adviser Condoleezza Rice promised Congress a full investigation into the allegations. But the Wall Street Journal reports that "there is little sign of progress in a federal investigation of allegations that he once leaked U.S. intelligence secrets to Iran."

CHALABI ACCUSED OF ENGAGING IN COUNTERFEITING OPERATION IN POST-WAR IRAQ: The AP reported in August 2004 that Iraq had issued an arrest warrant for Ahmad Chalabi on counterfeiting charges. The warrants "accused Ahmad Chalabi of counterfeiting old Iraqi dinars -- which had been removed from circulation following the fall of Saddam's regime last year. . .Police found the counterfeit money along with old dinars in Ahmad Chalabi's house during a May raid." A judge later dismissed the counterfeit charges for lack of evidence.

CHALABI CONVICTED FOR EMBEZZLEMENT: Critics have questioned the credibility of Ahmad Chalabi because in 1992 he was convicted by a Jordanian court of embezzling funds from a bank where he was employed. According to the Independent, "By 1992 he [Chalabi] was convicted in absentia of embezzlement and fraud, and his sentence of 22 years hard labour stands to this day. Jordan claims the debacle cost the state $300 million."

CHALABI CURRENTLY HEADING IRAQI OIL MINISTRY: Chalabi has maintained leadership over the oil ministry while also retaining the post of deputy prime minister in Iraq.

I and others have done quite a number of media interviews on Chalabi's attempts to burrow back into Washington respectability -- but I think that quite a bit of repellant has now been deployed.

I'll be watching closely on-line and will be on the phone all afternoon (eastern time) with the press.

I hope that those of you who care about making sure that Chalabi has an absolutely miserable time in the nation's capital followed by harrassment and headache in New York -- and skeptical headlines wherever he goes -- will be sure to greet him in the way he should be greeted today at 1150 17th Street, NW.

And those of you "in the room", be bold -- but reserved. Don't come off as a flamer when a public policy meeting is going on. Engage Chalabi seriously.

Your questions and views are important. AEI President Chris DeMuth may try to protect Chalabi -- or alternatively, Chris may be rough on him -- who knows? He may let Chalabi handle his own zinger queries -- but in either case, your views matter.

And your questions of Chalabi -- if constructed to make him accountable -- will put him on the line in front of a great number of cameras and scores of print journalists.

Good luck.

More later.

-- Steve Clemons

« Previous Article - New Yorkers: Arrest Ahmad Chalabi on Friday?
» Next Article - CHALABI News Flash: Congressman George Miller & Senator Dick Durbin Call for Him to be Subpoenaed

Reader Comments (15) - post a comment

Posted by Howie, Nov 09 2005, 10:45AM - Link

If this horses ass is wanted in Jordan and Jordan is our ally, why is he not in hand cuffs? This is a slap in the face to our allies that says we are giving him a free ride through our country. Why is the MSM not making an issue of this? This is administration might just as well say F@#k Off citizens we know what is best for this country, not you.

Posted by Tech Coed, Nov 09 2005, 11:07AM - Link

In June I attended my collge reunion which was also Chalabi's. (He did not come.) No one at the well attended reunion remembered him. I and my fellow math majors found this mysterious but apparantly he has been a man of mystery since his teenage years.

Posted by L Parke, Nov 09 2005, 12:12PM - Link

Since a burning question in everybody's mind is "where did the actual yellowcake forgeries originat" I hope somebody dares asks Chalabi about this May 24 New Yorker story...

"This about Chalabi's forgery shop is also quite intriguing, given the role forged documents seemed to play in the US's pre-war Iraq intel misestimates.

In retrospect, one detail of Chalabi’s operation seems particularly noteworthy. In 1994, Baer said, he went with Chalabi to visit “a forgery shop” that the I.N.C. had set up inside an abandoned schoolhouse in Salahuddin, a town in Kurdistan. “It was something like a spy novel,” Baer said. “It was a room where people were scanning Iraqi intelligence documents into computers, and doing disinformation. There was a whole wing of it that he did forgeries in.” Baer had no evidence that Chalabi forged any of the disputed intelligence documents that were used to foment alarm in the run-up to the war. But, he said, “he was forging back then, in order to bring down Saddam.” In the Los Angeles Times, Hugh Pope wrote of one harmless-seeming prank that emerged from Chalabi’s specialty shop: a precise mockup of an Iraqi newspaper that was filled with stories about Saddam’s human-rights abuses. Another faked document ended up directly affecting Baer. It was a copy of a forged letter to Chalabi, made to look as if it were written on the stationery of President Clinton’s National Security Council. The letter asked for Chalabi’s help in an American-led assassination plot against Saddam. “It was a complete fake,” Baer said, adding that he believed it was an effort to hoodwink the Iranians into joining a plot against Saddam; an indication of American involvement, Chalabi hoped, would convince them that the effort was serious. Brooke acknowledged that the I.N.C. had run a forgery shop, but denied that Chalabi had created the phony assassination letter. “That would be illegal,” he said. To Baer’s dismay, the letter eventually made its way to Langley, Virginia, and the C.I.A. accused him of being involved in the scheme. Baer said he had to pass a polygraph test in order to prove otherwise."


Posted by James Atkinson, Nov 09 2005, 12:14PM - Link

If Chalabi is traveling in the US as Deputy Prime Minister, wouldn't he be protected from arrest --- citizen's or otherwise --- by some sort of diplomatic privilege?

JA

Posted by L Parke, Nov 09 2005, 12:29PM - Link

That New Yorker story about Chalabi is one of a series of investigative reports the magazine evidently did about this bum, during May / June 2004. The link mentioned above is still online at http://www.newyorker.com/fact/content/articles/040607fa_fact1_b

Posted by Marica, Nov 09 2005, 12:34PM - Link

Where is Chalabi's old friend Richard Perle?

Posted by Red_Neck_Repub, Nov 09 2005, 12:47PM - Link

NJ - you knew that when Doug the Slimy Slug brought in Rudi Fooliani he was doomed. I hear he's inline for FEMA Director.

CA - Hasta la vista, Gropinator!!

NY - Little Mike is actually a long time semi-centrist Democrat who ran as a Repug because he couldn't win in the always crowded Demo primary. If not for 9/11 no one would ever heard of him. Ferrer is a nice guy but a lousy candidate.

Posted by LondonYank, Nov 09 2005, 1:24PM - Link

Don't forget Chalabi's huge CIA-funded forgery operation in Salahaddin, Northern Iraq, which was used for years to produce phoney "official" Iraqi government documents (and some US government documents). The forgery factory was acknowledged in the New Yorker article on Chalabi in 2004.

I've suspected that it was this forgery operation which was the source for the Oil for Food lists which implicated specific opponents of the US invasion of Iraq within the United Nations, France, India and Britain. Remember that the Oil for Food fraud allegations started from Chalabi after he took the ministry of oil records in 2003. The same forgery operation may also be the source of forged letters fomenting unrest in the Ahwazi Khuzestan region of Iran (holding 90 percent of proven oil reserves) and possibly connected to the Hariri investigation (recalling that Chalabi grew up in Beirut and has many connections there).

Chalabi forged the case for war. Let's not forget that he has the tools to forge the case for future wars and further damage still.

Posted by CtGlav, Nov 09 2005, 2:06PM - Link

AP report Wednesday:
Chalabi met with Sec'y Rice for 1/2 hour. He said it went very well.
Will have "face time with VP Dick Cheney and national security adviser Stephen Hadley"

McClellan: Chalabi's "seen as an elected leader of the Iraqi government and one of a number that we have met with in recent months."

http://www.nytimes.com/aponline/national/AP-US-Chalabi.html

Posted by Robert Morrow, Nov 09 2005, 3:39PM - Link

How about that MASSIVE 76-24% win for Proposition 2 down here in Texas as so-called "gay" marriage, a fantasy and biological impossibility, runs into the brick wall of reality with a more than 3-1 win for Marriage?
Bush on got 61% of the vote in Texas. The blacks and Hispanics, especially the churches, were absolutely RABID pro-Marriage, anti-gay agenda and the blacks, Hispanics, Republicans and churches were a BIG reason for the success of the Marriage proposition.
Note: 17 Texas dailies opposed Prop 2, including every major paper; no wonder their circulations are going down in flames.

Posted by jim in austin, Nov 09 2005, 4:28PM - Link

That was a 76%-24% win amongst 17.87% of the registered voters, which is historically high for an off-off-year election in Texas, especially with no state-wide candidates on the ballot. I would love to know what percentage went to the polls just because this piece of raw meat was waved in front of their eyes.

It was a pointless exercise in any case, since gay unions are now and always have been illegal in Texas and the Texas Supreme Court is filled with elected Republican judges. It is assumed that this was simply a "hook" to bring the faithful to the polls and ram through the 8 other constitutional amendments that were chocked full of carefully worded patronage and corporate welfare provisions.

BTW, the amendment was soundly defeated in Travis Co 40%-60%. As the saying here goes, "Hell, I ain't from Texas! I'm from Austin!"

Posted by atexan, Nov 09 2005, 8:45PM - Link

Hardball with Chris Matthews will also be featuring a full rundown on the Chalabi chronology on tomorrow's (Thursday) program.

Posted by Jim Preston, Nov 10 2005, 11:41AM - Link

I had signed up for the Chalabi speech in washington, and had by printed receipt and registration number from the AEI. The night before the speech, there was a message on my cell phone from AEI, explaining that "the event was oversubscribed and they would not be able to accept my registration." I showed up anyway, since I had the receipt, and was told at the door that no name tag was available for me because of a "database error." So I went outside and supported the protests. So, the Iraqi politicians are learning the Bush doctrine: Supporters only! What a surprise!

Posted by Eliot, Nov 10 2005, 10:58PM - Link

Thanks for the heads up on the Council on Foreign Relations appearance.

Posted by ANeutralVoice, Nov 12 2005, 11:28AM - Link

Could these links be a Republican ploy? Okay, Dick, Scooter, Tom, which one of you guys provided the porno links? The tactic will never work. You can’t change this sites legitimacy by merely placing disgusting pornographic links on it. Good try though!

The Washington Note - Steven ClemonsHome - About - Archives - Published - Recommended - Advertise - Contact
THIS SITE IS COPYRIGHT © 2010 THE WASHINGTON NOTE. ALL RIGHTS ARE RESERVED.